Page 64 of 65

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 3:15 pm
by Blakamiss

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 3:46 pm
by RottenAtom
Been waiting for a Whalen Ratatouille for awhile. Not a huge fan of this. The art is cool, but Ratatouille has the best color palette out of all the Pixar movies and I think not utilizing it is a missed opportunity.

Not trying to hate, but in my opinion the Cyclops posters by Tom aren't on the level of his other Disney posters (they were all fire before Cyclops got involved). I would love re-dos of Robin Hood, Ratatouille, and Inside Out. Love Whalen, love the movies, don't care for the posters or color choices.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 4:19 pm
by jkw3000
RottenAtom wrote:Been waiting for a Whalen Ratatouille for awhile. Not a huge fan of this. The art is cool, but Ratatouille has the best color palette out of all the Pixar movies and I think not utilizing it is a missed opportunity.

Not trying to hate, but in my opinion the Cyclops posters by Tom aren't on the level of his other Disney posters (they were all fire before Cyclops got involved). I would love re-dos of Robin Hood, Ratatouille, and Inside Out. Love Whalen, love the movies, don't care for the posters or color choices.
Interesting. I don't find Robin Hood or Inside Out to be all that different from the non-Cyclops Disney stuff - Inside Out in particular has a range of colors there, and Robin Hood feels like it fits with the range presented from the movie (with the greens seeming to pop more on a well-chosen gold variant). But I definitely see the point with respect to Ratatouille - matches the Duel at Dawn design in terms of the chosen color scheme, which seems to favor a more monochrome approach. Not my thing personally, though cool if it's other people's. Just curious as to the reasoning behind that approach on something like Ratatouille - a film that I'd agree with RA in that it has one of the best color palettes among the Pixar films.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 4:20 pm
by mfaith
Image Image

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 4:28 pm
by Kramerica
I don't see much difference between prints like Little Mermaid/Aladdin/Incredibles and Robin Hood/Jungle Book/inside out. Aside from the fact that the stuff printed by Eclipse is head and shoulders above d&l quality wise. There are exceptions like Toy Story and Nemo that offer a little more filled out composition.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 5:47 pm
by RottenAtom
jkw3000 wrote:
RottenAtom wrote:Been waiting for a Whalen Ratatouille for awhile. Not a huge fan of this. The art is cool, but Ratatouille has the best color palette out of all the Pixar movies and I think not utilizing it is a missed opportunity.

Not trying to hate, but in my opinion the Cyclops posters by Tom aren't on the level of his other Disney posters (they were all fire before Cyclops got involved). I would love re-dos of Robin Hood, Ratatouille, and Inside Out. Love Whalen, love the movies, don't care for the posters or color choices.
Interesting. I don't find Robin Hood or Inside Out to be all that different from the non-Cyclops Disney stuff - Inside Out in particular has a range of colors there, and Robin Hood feels like it fits with the range presented from the movie (with the greens seeming to pop more on a well-chosen gold variant). But I definitely see the point with respect to Ratatouille - matches the Duel at Dawn design in terms of the chosen color scheme, which seems to favor a more monochrome approach. Not my thing personally, though cool if it's other people's. Just curious as to the reasoning behind that approach on something like Ratatouille - a film that I'd agree with RA in that it has one of the best color palettes among the Pixar films.
The Inside Out poster is extremely white. That movie is full of bright, bold, beautiful colors in every frame and I don't get any of that from the poster. I get lots of white with a little bit of color mixed in. Not a fan of the girl's face all big like that. It just isn't an appealing poster to look at and I'm not a fan of the layout. That movie is super colorful and I wish the poster reflected that (needs more purple). The print has a lot of orange in it. The Robin Hood poster is also overwhelmingly orange and it doesn't have the colors that I remember from the movie (needs way more green). I wish he took a similar approach to Inside Out as he did with Finding Nemo. With Nemo being submerged in water, the print benefited from the non-white background in a way that I think Inside Out would've since it is submerged in the human mind.

I have a bunch of Whalen Disney prints (many are awesome prints for movies I'm not crazy about). Before Robin Hood, Inside Out, and Ratatouille were released, I was hoping for/anticipating posters for them. Perhaps my expectations were just too high, but for me they missed the mark and are underwhelming. Tom is still a master at what he does and a gd machine.

edit- My initial criticism of Cyclops may have been unfair. I like several of the posters they've done (Wall-E is especially nice), just not the ones mentioned.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 10:14 pm
by mfaith
Kramerica wrote:Aside from the fact that the stuff printed by Eclipse is head and shoulders above d&l quality wise.
FYI, I've been told that Eclipse is not longer a separate entity, and has effectively been absorbed into Cyclops proper. I asked about it when I started seeing "Printed by Cyclops Print Works" instead of Eclipse Workshop on recent listings (and wanted to make sure I had the correct info for the DB).

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2018 10:34 pm
by Kramerica
mfaith wrote:
Kramerica wrote:Aside from the fact that the stuff printed by Eclipse is head and shoulders above d&l quality wise.
FYI, I've been told that Eclipse is not longer a separate entity, and has effectively been absorbed into Cyclops proper. I asked about it when I started seeing "Printed by Cyclops Print Works" instead of Eclipse Workshop on recent listings (and wanted to make sure I had the correct info for the DB).
I was curious about that wording as well.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 1:26 am
by Codeblue
They were basically the same entity anyway was my understanding.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 5:50 am
by playa787
Came to say how bland the colors on the Ratatouille piece were. Ya'll beat me to it. Thats two strikes for Ratatouille posters.(not counting those pieces from the soundtrack) Lets hope a third time is the charm. I think Landland would kill it.
But I do wonder if that comes down to artist choice vs how many colors the gallery is willing to pay for/ask for.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 6:56 am
by earlgreytoast
The regular is fine but jeez, what’s the point of having a variant that is so similar and bland? Boring af. I love the design.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 7:26 am
by playa787
earlgreytoast wrote:The regular is fine but jeez, what’s the point of having a variant that is so similar and bland? Boring af. I love the design.
Variant looks like if the reg was left out in direct sunlight for a few years.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 9:09 am
by BallandBiscuit
I too, was excited about a Whalen Ratatouille print but like most of you, was underwhelmed by the color choices. Not sure what went wrong there. Maybe they have an overstock of that brown/tan/orange type of ink from Duel at Dawn. Perhaps Cyclops has a secret variant in the works with more appropriate coloring? Doubtful but one can hope.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 10:38 am
by 35mmpaul
Looks like the same coloring of the movie to me.

Image

Image

the overhead lighting in the kitchen is a little brighter. but overall its got the earthy and grey tones of the film.

Re: Cyclops Print Works: Release and Discussion Thread

Posted: Fri Apr 20, 2018 10:55 am
by jkw3000
The issue isn't that it lands on a color that's faithful to the film, it's that the range stays monochrome instead of having any contrasting secondary colors. It's a choice that I understand for Duel at Dawn because of the Western angle, though I'm curious as to its application for a Ratatouille print when the expectation would skew more towards the other, less monochrome Disney posters he's done.