I'm skipping the Islay part of your post, because it is not my thing.bmd1191 wrote:A question for my scotch lovers. I relatively new to the scotch world and have only been drinking trying different brands the last year or so. I started out with the lighter speysides like glenlivet, macallan, balvenie. Then a little while ago I picked up a bottle of Highland Park 12 and I really loved it. I loved the little smokey/peat taste it had on the finish as it wasn't overbearing and you could still taste the other flavors.
Only brown liquor I've found so far that I did not like.
Highland Park is a superlative dram.
I'm not sure there's many better in that price range, if any.
When you tried The Glenlivet, did you hit up their 15YO "French Oak" version?
If not, I think you will like it a lot.
I know I'll get flamed for this, but also consider some blended Scotch.
Some are marriages of 100% single malts, and even the ones that aren't are products of no small amount of expertise love and care.
As with any spirit, some you will like, some not so much.
Blends made with finer whiskies will be more expensive, of course.